Nine months have passed since the graphic novel “Flamer” was first removed from school library shelves in Harford County, and though the school system says it followed outlined procedures for determining whether the book is appropriate for school-aged readers, conflicting decisions made along the way have landed the case in Harford County Circuit Court.
“Flamer,” a 2020 semi-autobiographical graphic novel by Mike Curato about a teen boy who struggles with his sexuality, was the first novel challenged under Harford County Public Schools’ newly formed Library Materials Reconsideration Committee. The 27-member committee was created to evaluate books community members want banned from school libraries.
In June, the Harford County Board of Education voted to remove “Flamer” from school libraries, even though the committee approved it for middle- and high-school levels. A group of community members — including Leslie Thompson, a parent of two Harford Schools students — appealed the decision to the Maryland State Board of Education.
The state board overturned the local board’s removal in November, placing “Flamer” back on Harford Schools shelves and pointing to fissures in the school system’s review process. That same month, the local school board decided to challenge the state board’s decision, requesting a judicial review in the county’s circuit court. Now, parents and school officials are waiting to see what a judge decides, with no clear deadline.
The first evaluation
Pete Hicks, a Harford Schools library media specialist, was part of the Library Materials Reconsideration subcommittee that first evaluated “Flamer.” He described it as an “eye-opening” experience and said he was disappointed by the Harford school board’s decision to remove the book from shelves despite the group’s recommendation.
Hicks, who served as an alternate and non-voting member on the subcommittee, said the challenger openly admitted they did not read the book. Hicks said it was tricky for the committee to decide whether to look at the book in “good faith” or analyze the challenge itself.
“I think everyone took it very seriously, and we all tried to do our best to be diligent, respectful and responsible,” he said. “It just didn’t go the way I thought it would, based on the work we put into it.”
When choosing to remove the book, Harford Board of Education members pointed to sexually explicit language and inappropriateness for young audiences. Then-school board president Aaron Poynton said the committee’s approval violated school system standards by allowing middle schoolers access to the book, adding that the board was forced into a binary decision to either keep it in middle and high schools or remove it altogether.
“By its own publisher’s recommendation, ‘Flamer’ is designed for grades 10 through 12. Yet it was sitting in middle school libraries, accessible to children as young as 10 or 11,” Poynton wrote in a letter to the editor of The Aegis in August.
The local chapter of Moms for Liberty, a conservative parent group, has supported the school board’s decision to remove the book. Representatives from the chapter read out loud during school board public comment periods sections of the book, saying its mature themes were not appropriate for young students.
But after “Flamer” was removed, a group of community members who felt differently appealed the decision to the state Board of Education.
The appeal alleged the Harford school board’s choice lacked transparency and violated the Maryland Freedom to Read Act.
Thompson, a parent of two Harford Schools students, said decisions about what children should be exposed to should be up to a child’s parents.
“That’s our job,” she said. “We have to make sure our kids are exposed to different perspectives, different experiences and be able to talk through hard things … if we ignore things, shove things under the rug and just pretend things don’t exist in this world, that’s not setting anybody up to be successful and safe.”
The state’s decision to restore the book to shelves also recommended that the school board revise its book evaluation procedures to “ensure transparency, provide notice and opportunity for community participation and future reconsideration matters.”
It was the first time the state had intervened in a local decision determining what’s appropriate for students to read. Some Harford school board members felt it was an overstep.
“The job of the Board of Education is to reflect the values of the community,” said appointed member Mark Korn, during a November meeting. “What’s the purpose of a county Board of Education if it’s going to be overridden by the state? Just have the state run it all.”
Seeing it through
Thompson was among several community members to appeal the decision to the state. Her request was the only one deemed to have standing with the state board, since she currently has children in Harford Schools, one in high school and another in elementary school.
The legal process for the judicial review has just officially begun in Harford County Circuit Court, and Thompson said there’s no clear date for when to expect a decision. The case will largely be examined by a judge via documents and neither side will have to appear in court.
Thompson said the fight isn’t necessarily about this one book, but rather about the Board of Education attempting to remove things that make the county diverse.
“It’s really disheartening that a group of people would use their personal bias to make these kinds of decisions for an entire school district,” she said.
Moms For Liberty also expressed frustration at the process.
In a statement, the chapter’s new chair William Martino said: “The review process is long and tedious. Many parents wouldn’t power through all the administrative layers. After two years, one parent had the fortitude to complete everything and was victorious, then the state over turns the will of the county. This was discouraging to say the least.”
Since the state’s decision, the county’s Evaluation and Selection of School Library Material procedure has been adjusted to include more opt-out options and transparency, according to Poynton.
In August, Poynton said he wanted to add “quantifiable metrics” to the procedure to avoid leaving decisions “open to interpretation” by the committee or board members.
“This is not about silencing voices or removing diverse perspectives. I oppose censorship,” he said in a letter to the Aegis. “It is about applying standards consistently and restoring trust in public education. Confidence in K-12 schools is already at historic lows. Ignoring our own rules erodes that trust even further.”
Have a news tip? Contact Shaela Foster at sfoster@baltsun.com or 443-826-5894.

Leave A Comment