The extreme politicization of a minor change to the hepatitis B vaccine recommendation by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) is a danger to public health. Maryland families deserve to know what the change actually means. ACIP is still recommending the birth dose to any babies that are at high risk of contracting hepatitis B. A baby would be considered high risk if the mother tested positive or has an unknown status. In the state of Maryland, all pregnant mothers are already tested for hepatitis B in pregnancy. The birth dose was not removed. For low-risk babies, the new recommendation was simply shifted to eight weeks with a series of other immunizations recommended at that time. That move put the U.S. in line with the vast majority of industrialized nations.
Public health entities, with their manufactured outrage and over-sensationalized media headlines, are causing further harm to the already tenuous relationship between parents and the public health sector. COVID-19 and the way it was handled by public health organizations caused significant damage to public trust in medicine. And having outsized public temper tantrums to small, reasonable changes to the schedule is doing nothing to restore the public’s faith.
Shifting from the one-size-fits-all birth dose at 24 hours old to a thoughtful, individualized medical assessment is a completely reasonable move. The change is in line with Next Gen Medicine in this post-AI world. Individualized, tailored medical care, especially in a vulnerable population, is the new gold standard in care. Children are not cars whose gas tanks can simply be carelessly overfilled. A blood test to confirm immunity is a safe and reasonable offering that parents should have access to at no additional cost.
The hepatitis B vaccine was originally rolled out for high-risk adults, primarily sex workers and intravenous drug users, but uptake was very low in the 1980s. So, the CDC first pivoted to vaccinating all newborns in 1991 because, according to Dr. Richard Aach in a 1991 New York Times article, the manufacturer’s original strategy of vaccinating adults “has not been well received” and was totally ineffective at gaining compliance. Almost 60% of today’s U.S. population was born before 1991 — I know I was — and none of us got the birth dose of the hepatitis B vaccine; many of us haven’t had a single dose.
When it was added to the childhood schedule, thanks to the 1986 National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act and Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, it was granted complete liability protection. If your child is ever harmed by this and most other childhood vaccines, you cannot sue the manufacturer directly; instead, you go to the government. To date, the U.S. government has paid out $5.4 billion in damages to vaccine recipients.
It’s disheartening and frankly dangerous to see that public health has become such a hyperpolarized issue in this post-COVID world. Gov. Wes Moore recently joined the Northeast Public Health Collaborative. After weeks of attempts at getting information from his administration about the collaborative, there are more questions than answers. Who in Maryland is participating, and what policy is coming out of it? Thus far, it appears they’re doing nothing other than offering yet another alternative recommendation for vaccinations, sending a clear-as-mud message to the public about who to look to for information.
Pushing the public to ignore the CDC over a reasonable shift in recommendations from all babies at birth to high-risk babies at birth and all babies at eight weeks is so incredibly short-sighted. It will likely undermine the entire public health care sector further as more and more families receive contradictory information and head to “Dr. Google” instead. In such a scenario, the best one could hope for is that they come across information that shows among the 37 countries assessed by the CDC in 2025, “26 implement selective HepB-BD (birth dose) for infants born to HBsAg-positive women,” just as ACIP has just recommended.
Next Gen Medicine means moving away from the one-size-fits-all medical recommendations that were made popular in the 19th century. Individualized, tailored medicine that asks the right questions is here to stay. Is the patient high risk? Is the patient already immune? It’s not too much effort for our most precious and vulnerable patients, our babies. I hope that the public health Mafia that all but totally lost credibility during COVID will calm down and join the rest of the grown-ups at the big kids table, where practitioners are using critical thinking skills to create individualized medical plans based on the actual patient and not treating infants like they’re on an assembly line. You know, like they’re already doing in places like the U.K. and Sweden. Cut the drama, or families will stop listening to public health experts for good.
Lauren Arikan (lauren.arikan@house.state.md.us) is a Republican delegate representing District 7B in Harford County.

Leave A Comment