Former Harford County Council member Aaron Penman has appealed a Supreme Court of Maryland ruling that removed him from his seat in February 2025. Now, he is running to “reclaim” that position, pending the appeal’s outcome.
Penman, a Republican, filed to run for the seat representing Joppa, Abingdon, Bel Air, Fallston and Forest Hill.
He was removed from the position after the state’s highest court ruled he could not serve in the role and maintain his employment as a sergeant with the Harford County Sheriff’s Office, saying this violated state ethics laws.
In a post on social media announcing his candidacy, Penman said he believes deputy sheriffs operate within offices that are “uniquely independent” and separate from traditional state and local government structures.
“This is bigger than one seat. It’s about ensuring that public safety professionals are not excluded from local government,” Penman said. “We should not be treated differently when we are willing to step up and serve in both capacities.”
Penman initially retired from his position with the Sheriff’s Office a month before his election in 2022 out of concern that the county charter wouldn’t permit him to serve in both capacities. Following a Supreme Court of Maryland ruling that allowed District F Council member Jacob Bennett to keep his seat and his position as a teacher with Harford County Public Schools, Penman ended his retirement and was rehired by the sheriff’s office.
His reemployment sparked ethics complaints to both the local and state ethics commissions, as well as the case that eventually came before the state Supreme Court.
In the Facebook post, Penman said he disagreed with the ruling that ultimately removed him from the council. His appeal, Penman said, had a hearing in early January, and he is waiting on a ruling from the Appellate Court of Maryland that will determine his eligibility to serve on the council.
“While my passion and priority will remain an active member of the law enforcement community, I also remain committed to serving the residents of District B and pursuing a fair resolution that could impact communities across our state,” Penman’s post said. “I have fought too hard to walk away now.”
Penman will be running against six candidates — one of whom is Republican Alison Imhoff, who was appointed by the council to fill the District B vacancy left by Penman’s removal.
Penman was the second council member to be removed from his seat in a matter of about four months, following former District A Councilman Dion Guthrie, a Democrat, who lost his position after pleading no contest to felony theft charges in late 2024.
Guthrie has launched a campaign to reclaim his District A seat.
The primary will be June 23.
Have a news tip? Contact Matt Hubbard at mhubbard@baltsun.com, 443-651-0101 or @mthubb on X.

Leave A Comment